Revise, Reflect, Refine
Which observation best supports the idea that sound is a mechanical wave? (i) Sound shows reflection (ii) Sound needs a medium to propagate (iii) Sound has frequency (iv) Sound carries energy
A mechanical wave is defined as a wave that requires a material medium (solid, liquid, or gas) for its propagation — it transfers energy through the oscillation of the medium's particles.
(i) Reflection is a property of all waves, including electromagnetic waves; it does not distinguish mechanical from non-mechanical waves.
(ii) Sound cannot travel through vacuum. This is precisely because it is a mechanical wave — it needs particles of the medium to vibrate and pass the disturbance forward. Electromagnetic waves (light, radio) need no medium, so the requirement of a medium directly identifies sound as mechanical.
(iii) Frequency is a property of any periodic wave; it does not indicate whether a medium is needed.
(iv) All waves carry energy; energy transport alone does not indicate a mechanical wave.
Answer: (ii) Sound needs a medium to propagate.
